Articles
Public vs. Private Long-Term Health Centers with Government Contracts: What Are the Differences for Families?
- Catégories : Long term care facility, Senior home living
- Temps de lecture : 10 minutes
Choosing long-term care for a loved one who has lost a significant degree of independence is a major decision. In Quebec, there are three main types of long-term care facilities (CHSLDs): public, private-contracted, and private-non-contracted. Although the first two are part of the healthcare network and offer the same level of care, there are administrative and financial differences. Understanding these nuances is essential to making an informed choice.
The three models of CHSLDs in Quebec
The main distinction lies in ownership and, above all, in how care is funded by the government.
- Public CHSLD
These facilities are government-owned and are directly administered by the regional CIUSSS or CISSS. The staff are employed by the public sector. - Private CHSLD with Government Agreement (EPC)
The building is privately owned, but the facility has signed an agreement (convention) with the government. The CIUSSS/CISSS funds all care services. - Non-Conventioned Private CHSLD (PNC)
These facilities are entirely private. They hold a license to provide care but are not subsidized by the government for care and services.
Access to Care: Public and Contracted vs. Non-Contracted
The first major difference for families concerns who covers the cost of care.
The Public Model: Controlled Access and Universal Care
In Public and Private Contracted CHSLDs, the model is the same:
- Free care: All medical, nursing, and assistance care is paid for by the RAMQ.
- Single admission: Access is controlled by the public system. The individual must be assessed by the CIUSSS/CISSS and placed on the regional waiting list. Families have no control over the assigned facility (public or government-contracted).
The private, non-contracted model: Direct admission and full costs
In a Non-Contracted Private CHSLD, the rules regarding access and costs are different:
- Pay-for-care: The family is responsible for paying not only for accommodation but also for the full cost of care.
- Direct admission: The facility manages its own admission process and is not subject to the CIUSSS/CISSS waiting list. The family can contact the facility directly.
The impact on accommodation costs for the family
This is the most significant difference, aside from care costs. The financial contribution from the senior varies greatly.
Uniform cost: Public and Private Contracted
In Public and Private Contracted CHSLDs, the cost of accommodation is set by the government (RAMQ) and is the same. This contribution is based on the resident’s income and covers housing (room, meals, bedding, etc.). This model allows families to avoid going into debt for care.
Unregulated Cost: Non-Conventioned Private Facilities
In non-conventioned private CHSLDs, the facility is free to set its own rates. The cost includes accommodation, meals, and all care and assistance services. Consequently, the monthly cost is significantly higher and can represent a considerable financial burden for the family.
| CHSLD | Management | Care (Funding) | Accommodation Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Public | Public (CIUSSS/CISSS) | RAMQ (Free) | RAMQ (Set based on income) |
| Private (Contracted) | Private (Contract with the government) | RAMQ (Free) | RAMQ (Income-based) |
| Private Non-Contracted | Private (Independent) | Family (Private) | Open Market (Set by the facility) |
The choice of a CHSLD is primarily determined by the level of care required and the assessment of the public system. For families, the key financial distinction lies between the model where care is publicly funded (Public/Conventional) and the model where care is entirely at the family’s expense (Private Non-Conventional). Understanding these nuances is essential for planning your loved one’s future with peace of mind.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Private facilities not under the public health care system must hold a license and comply with standards of care. However, since pricing is unregulated and care is funded entirely by private sources, the quantity and quality of services may vary from one facility to another.
Yes, this is possible for all three types of CHSLDs, but the nature of the eligible expense differs:
Public and Private Contracted: The monthly accommodation fee required by the RAMQ is eligible for the tax credit, as it covers room and board.
Non-Contracted Private: Fees for personal care services (assistance with dressing, hygiene, meals, etc.) paid directly to the facility are eligible, just as they are in a private seniors’ residence (RPA).
No. If a person is residing in a private, non-contracted long-term care facility and can no longer afford the costs, they must submit a new request for assessment to the CIUSSS/CISSS in order to be placed on the waiting list for a public or contracted long-term care facility.
Mandala Santé's offering in Long-term Health Centers :
Articles